Monday, July 16, 2012



All right-thinking persons should be concerned over the growing negative mood in Indian public opinion.

This started in the wake of the various scams last year, exposing large-scale corruption and financial irregularities and public impressions of favouritism in seeking to appoint wrong persons to important posts such as that of the Chief Vigilance Commissioner.
It got aggravated by the shockingly insensitive manner in which the Government and some of its senior Ministers handled the public protest against corruption spearheaded by Anna Hazare and Baba Ramdev and by the Government’s dragging its feet in pushing though the Lokpal Bill.

The public mood has further worsened due to the increasingly negative economic indicators relating to inflation, GDP growth date, industrial production, the value of the rupee etc.

The Chinese economy has also been going through a bad patch. Its GDP growth rate that used to record 10 per cent plus year after year for nearly a decade has come down below 10 per cent and has reached a three-year low of around 8 per cent in the recent quarter. The number of internal disturbances due to economic factors such as anger in public over arbitrary ways of acquiring land is increasing. The Chinese Government and Communist Party are more worried about the dangers of internal instability due to economic factors than ever before.

There is a negative mood in China too, but that doesn’t get reflected in its controlled media, but one can see signs of it in the debates among its rapidly growing community of netizens.

Foreign opinion-makers, who have their own agenda against  India due to factors such as our Prime Minister’s political weaknesses and constraints, which come in the way of his pushing ahead with economic reforms, have been wittingly or unwittingly adding to the negative mood in India by the way they project our Prime Minister as indecisive, as an underachiever, as a political non-entity etc.

There is a vicious circle of the criticism and negative projection of the Prime Minister by domestic and foreign analysts feeding each other.

As a result, the Prime Minister finds himself being relentlessly stoned by his critics at home as well as abroad.

I have been a strong critic of the Prime Minister and his weak style of leadership.

I have also been an equally strong critic of his failure or reluctance to impose his authority on those around him.

His reluctance or inability or both to lead from the front and take effective charge of the ship of the Indian State has added to the negative mood.

It is important for the Prime Minister to realise that ONLY HE and nobody else can arrest this spreading negativism.

This calls for policy initiatives, decision initiatives and strong activism and leadership assertion.

Initiatives are urgently required in matters  such as action against corruption, control of inflation, pushing through urgently needed economic reforms and repeatedly engaging with the public instead of continuing to disengage from them.

The Prime Minister continues to lead from inside a well instead of from the deck of the ship of the Indian State.

His leadership is unfelt, unseen.

His voice is feeble and unheard.

His senior advisers, who are defensive in the face of increasing public criticism, are letting him down by failing to vigorously counter the negative mood.

They seem to be thinking: When the Prime Minister is reluctant to assert himself why should we do so and stick our neck out?

Even some good initiatives taken by the Government have not been properly projected to the public in matters such as better handling of counter-terrorism, avoiding the injection of more poison into our relations with Pakistan and reducing the trust deficit with China.

Even if these initiatives are  properly projected to the public, that alone will not counter the negative public mood unless bread and butter issues are addressed head-on.

A message has to go to the Indian public that the Prime Minister is in charge and is determined to reverse the negative public mood.

It is important for him to be felt.

It is important for him to be respected.

It is important for him to be feared.

Low profile, non-assertive leadership will not instil confidence in the public.

I had said this before and am saying it again.

The starting point of the exercise towards leadership assertion has to be vigorous and sustained interactions with carefully selected sections of our media.

A media kept groping for answers to important questions of State policy can damage the image of the PM.

That’s is what is happening now.

He should explain his worries, concerns, hopes and determination to act to the people through the media.

Social networks with periodic Tweets cannot serve this purpose.

Only frequent face-to-face interviews to important journalists will help.

We need to see the PM more and more on our TV screens.

We need to see him more and more in newspaper columns.

We need to see our Prime Minister as a picture  of physical and intellectual vigour.

The exercise to use the media for a better projection of himself , his policies and his hopes and vision for the future  has to be accompanied by an exercise to look for more opportunities to interact directly with the people.

The PM needs a team of imaginative, innovative, self-confident and positive minded media advisers who will keep the media and through it the public informed of the policy and decision initiatives of the PM and his Cabinet.

It is time for the PM to let the word spread that HE MEANS BUSINESS. (17-7-12)

( The writer is Additional Secretary (retd), Cabinet Secretariat, Govt of India, New Delhi, and, presently, Director, Institute For Topical Studies, Chennai, and Associate, Chennai Centre For China Studies. E-Mail: . Twitter: @SORBONNE75 )