Monday, June 4, 2012



Tibetans, both in the occupied Tibetan areas of China and in the diaspora, are increasingly frustrated by what they perceive as the ambivalent attitude of President Barack Obama on the continued unrest in the Tibetan areas of China and the violations of the human rights of the Tibetans by Beijing.

2.The Obama Administration, like its predecessor administrations, treats His Holiness the Dalai Lama with due courtesies during his periodic visits to Washington DC. These courtesies include unofficial meetings between the President and His Holiness.

3. The Obama Administration has also been periodically voicing its unhappiness and concern over the continued violations of the human rights of the Tibetans by Beijing and urging it to resume  the now-stalled  talks with the representatives of His Holiness.

4. But the Tibetans expected  a greater activism by the US in view of the increasingly grim situation prevailing in the Tibetan areas since March 2011 following the protests of the monks of the Kirti monastery in Sichuan against the continued Han colonisation of the Tibetan areas. The monks have also been demanding the return of His Holiness to Lhasa to take over the religious leadership of his people.

5. This grim situation has been marked by nearly 40 self-immolation attempts by both Tibetan men and women, detention without trial of defiant monks of the Kirti monastery in a military camp of Sichuan and forcibly subjecting many monks and others to what the Chinese call re-education. During these re-education classes, they are forced to denounce His Holiness and swear loyalty to the Chinese Government and Communist Party.

6. This grim situation, which initially started in Sichuan, subsequently spread to Qinghai and Gansi and is recently showing signs of spreading to Lhasa in the Tibet Autonomous Region (TAR) bordering on India and Nepal. Lhasa saw two self-immolation attempts on May 27 by monks who had come from outside the TAG.

7. Sources say that following the incidents in Lhasa, nearly about 3000 members of the Chinese security forces have undertaken house-to-house enquiries to locate and arrest Tibetans who had come to Lhasa  from outside the TAG and send them back to their provinces. About 600 local monks and others have reportedly been rounded up and shifted to a military camp of Lhasa for so-called re-education.

8. The details of the grim situation are well known to international human rights organisations, including the Human Rights Watch of the US. They have been highlighting these violations and demanding for over a year that international human rights observers should be allowed to visit the detention camp set up by Beijing in Sichuan, but the Chinese authorities have ignored these demands with contempt.

9. They have also been ignoring with contempt the periodic exhortations from Washington DC to resume talks with the representatives of His Holiness. The Chinese have repeatedly made it clear that any talks with the representatives of His Holiness will be on the personal future of His Holiness and not on the future of the Tibetan areas under Chinese occupation. They do not recognise the right of His Holiness to negotiate on behalf of the Tibetan people.

10. In the face of this political deadlock and deteriorating human rights situation, Tibetan hopes that during her recent visit to Beijing  Mrs. Hillary Clinton, the US Secretary of State, would take up vigorously the grim human rights situation in the Tibetan areas were belied.

11. It is this disappointment and frustration that are reflected in the decision on May 31,2012, of two senior advisers of His Holiness ---- Lodi Gyari and Kelsang Gyaltsen--- to resign from leadership positions in the team constituted by His Holiness to hold talks with the authorities of the Chinese Communist Party from time to time.

12.In an announcement, they  "expressed their utter frustration over the lack of positive response from the Chinese side.” While they have attributed their resignations, which have been accepted by the Tibetan Government-in-exile, to their frustration over the negative Chinese attitude, it is reliably understood that the hesitation of the Obama Administration to vigorously take up with Beijing the grim human rights situation has also contributed to their frustration, but they have not mentioned so in public.

13.His Holiness, who is no longer involved in the day-to-day running of the Government-in-exile, has not so far commented on the resignations, but it is unlikely that the two would have taken the decision without informally consulting His Holiness beforehand. Beijing is unlikely to be moved by their resignations. It is to be seen what impact it has on the Obama Administration.

14.A statement issued by the Government-in-exile after accepting their resignations  urged Beijing to accept the Dalai Lama's "middle-way" approach, which seeks genuine autonomy for Tibetans within China and within the framework of the Chinese constitution. It said: "This is a win-win proposition, which contributes to PRC’s unity, stability, harmony and its peaceful rise in the world."

15.The Tibetan task force on the negotiations with Beijing will be expanded and will meet again in December to discuss the Chinese leadership transition with the hope of continuing a dialogue with the new Chinese leaders to peacefully resolve the issue of Tibet, the statement said.

16. The Tibetans see no likelihood of any forward movement in addressing the grievances of the Tibetans in view of the forthcoming leadership transition in Beijing and the US Presidential elections. The Government-in-exile has, therefore, decided to wait till the end of the year. What impact this will have on the grim ground situation in the Tibetan areas  remains to be seen.(5-6-12)

( The writer is Additional Secretary (retd), Cabinet Secretariat, Govt of India, New Delhi, and, presently, Director, Institute For Topical Studies, Chennai, and Associate, Chennai Centre For China Studies. E-Mail: . Twitter: @SORBONNE75 )